Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

8th Grade Research and Communications Class: Debate Information

Grading Rubric

Speaker:

Topic:

Grade (out of 100 points):

CONTENT (50 pts.)

 

Seriousness towards topic                                                                                                  E   G   A  F   P

               

Ethos - Established credibility/goodwill as speaker on topic                                       E   G   A   F  P

 

Pathos – Used emotional conviction, examples, and language                                 E   G   A   F  P

 

Logos – Used proper evidence and sound reasoning                                                    E   G   A   F  P

 

Citing at least 2 sources throughout debate                                                                   E   G   A   F  P

 

Responsiveness to opponent’s arguments                                                                      E   G   A   F  P

 

Cross-examination sessions (Asking)                                                                              E   G   A   F  P

 

Cross-examination sessions (Asking)                                                                              E   G   A   F  P             

STRUCTURE (20 pts.)

 

Presented clear main points – at least 3                                                                          E   G   A   F  P

 

Employed an appropriate introduction and conclusion                                                              E   G   A   F  P

 

Used an appropriate organizational pattern for the speech                                        E   G   A   F  P

DELIVERY (30 pts.)

 

Maintained eye contact with the audience                                                                    E   G   A   F  P

 

Used notecards to guide speech                                                                                        E   G   A   F  P

 

Met time limits     (Deductions: __________________)                                             E   G   A   F  P

                                                                                               

Appropriate poise , gestures                                                                                                E   G   A   F  P

Overall Comments and Suggestions:

 

Debate terms

Persuasion

Aristotle

Ethos - Experience and Honesty

Pathos - Emotion

Logos - Logic/Sense

Claim - Assertion

Warrant - Proof

Logical fallacy

Ad Hominem fallacy

Causation Fallacy

Part/Whole Confusion

Format of Debate

Con speaks first, Pro Second

Con 1 (2 min)

Cross-examination (1 min)

Pro 1

Cross-examination

Con 2 (2 min)

Pro 2 (2 min)

Con 3 (30 secs)

Pro 3 (30 secs)