Skip to main content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Israel and Palestine (Lawrence): Home

Assignment Details

Mr. Lawrence

8th Cultural Geography

Big Red Peace Conference

 

During class on Friday, we will conduct a simulation of peace negotiations between the interested parties in the Middle East.  You will be assigned to teams in groups of three to four, will research the position you are assigned to represent, and will then negotiate in keeping with your side’s position.  I expect you to work together as a team and to abide by the negotiation rules and guidelines below.

 

TEAMS

Israel – settler living in the West Bank

Israel – Likud party member

Palestinian – Fatah member from West Bank

Palestinian – Hamas member from Gaza

 

Using the resources below, you should be prepared to discuss Israeli/Palestinian issues reflecting the views of your assigned group. Topics for discussion/debate should include the following:

1.Palestinian statehood

2.boundaries for Israel and Palestine

3.status of Jerusalem and the Temple Mount / Haram al-Sharif

4.status of refugees and right-of-return

5.disposition of Israeli settlements in West Bank

6.Israeli security from suicide bombings and rocket attacks

 

GUIDELINES/FORMAT FOR NEGOTIATIONS

-all discussions will take place in an environment of mutual respect and courtesy; be polite even if you disagree vehemently

-each side will identify itself briefly and then present its case for a just resolution

-each presentation will be followed by a question/answer period

-following all the presentations, sides will discuss possible compromises in an orderly fashion

-The more actual data (statistics, figures, true stories, etc) you bring to the table, the more convincing you will be.  The minimum acceptable effort will be knowing what your side’s view on each of the issues is; much more desirable will be actually having solid arguments and support for those arguments.

-ALL team members should participate!!

 

Position Papers: Due Wednesday – Using between 1/2 and 2/3 page for each topic/issue, identify your group and explain your group’s viewpoint on 2 major topic/issues (as viewed on next page) in the Israeli/Palestinian conflict.  Cite your sources at the end of each position paper (2 sources minimum per position)

 

Group Position File: Due Thursday at the end of class – Using a shared google document, combine Position Papers into one Position File that you will universally reference during the Peace Conference on Friday.

 

Resources (reading assignment)

MBA Library Databases – “Points of View” under ‘Current Events’ – username ‘mba’ password ‘big red’ ****read the article “Israel & the Palestinians: An Overview”****

MBA Library Databases – “Opposing Viewpoints in Context” under ‘Current Events’ – password ‘elvis’

Freedomhouse.org reports on Israel, West Bank, and Gaza

 

Format:

 

  • Brief introductions

  • Topic 1 – Palestine Statehood

  • Topic 2 – Boundaries for States

  • Topic 3 – Jerusalem Status and Temple Mount/Al-Shariff

  • Topic 4 - Status of Refugees / Right of Return

  • Topic 5 – Dispossession / Status of Israeli Settlements on the West Bank

  • Topic 6 – Israeli Security from Rocket Attacks / Suicide Bombings

  • Topic 7 – SURPRISE Water Rights (aquifer under West Bank)

 

Proposition –

Questioning –

Response –

Questioning –

Summation - 

 

Vote –




 

Group Grading will be evaluated as follows:

 

Most Convincing: maximum total - 100

 

More Convincing: maximum total - 95

 

Moderately Convincing: maximum total - 90

 

Least Convincing: maximum total - 85

 

Individual Grades will be averaged with the group grade for each Project score.

 

Librarian